MYGA lead generation can work without buying contact lists and chasing strangers. In this client campaign, we generated self-booked appointments for $395 using Facebook and Instagram ads.
The client wanted people with more than $200,000 in investable assets, but only in a few states. That smaller audience made the result particularly interesting.
Below, I’ll explain the system we built, what we tested, and why we stopped one channel to focus on another. The video shows the behind-the-scenes breakdown.
Want help generating qualified MYGA appointments for your own firm? Schedule a call with us to discuss your audience, geography, and campaign.
The client’s goal: MYGA prospects with $200,000+ in investable assets
MYGA stands for multi-year guaranteed annuity. It’s a fixed annuity with an interest rate guaranteed for a specified term, subject to the contract.
But the marketing challenge wasn’t simply explaining the product name.
Our client wanted to reach people interested in earning more interest on excess cash. These prospects might otherwise consider a bank savings account or a certificate of deposit, commonly called a CD.
The campaign’s minimum prospect profile was more than $200,000 in investable assets. That was a qualification target, not a claim that everyone should put that amount into an annuity.
Geography was the other important constraint.
This client advertised in only a few states. They weren’t giving Meta the same audience size as a firm running nationwide campaigns.
In my experience, smaller geographic audiences often cost more per appointment. I’ve seen that across clients advertising locally, in selected states, and more broadly.
So before launching, I estimated that this campaign might produce appointments for about $500 to $700 each.
The benchmark needs to fit the campaign. A limited-state MYGA campaign isn’t the same as a nationwide retirement-planning campaign.
The client’s identity remains private because the video shares behind-the-scenes campaign information. You can see public client testimonials and results if you’d like other examples of our work.
The MYGA appointment system we built
We built a system designed to take someone from first discovering the client to booking a qualified conversation.
That meant connecting the ads, video, application, calendar, and follow-up. Each part needed to support the same message.
The core journey was:
- Discover the client through an ad about a relevant cash-management problem.
- Watch a short video sales letter explaining the approach and alternatives.
- Complete an application so the firm can assess fit.
- Book a call through the calendar.
- Reach a confirmation page with additional information before the appointment.
For this client, the video sales letter was about five minutes long. It explained the MYGA approach alongside alternatives such as CDs and savings accounts.
The idea wasn’t to ask a stranger to book immediately without understanding anything.
Instead, the prospect could learn what the client offered before taking the next step. The application then helped qualify the inquiry before calendar booking.
You can see the wider structure in our appointment funnel guide. This case study shows how we applied that structure to a specific MYGA offer.
Why we tested sending paid traffic straight to the video
Our appointment systems can include an initial opt-in page before the video. In the past, that was usually where we sent traffic.
But we’ve also tested sending paid traffic directly to the video page across client campaigns.
In some of those tests, that produced a lower cost per appointment. I’ve found it especially useful when targeting people with higher investable assets.
That doesn’t mean every working funnel needs its opt-in page removed.
If an existing setup is converting well, I don’t want to change it simply because another approach worked elsewhere. The data should justify the change.
The important lesson is to test the route to a qualified booking. Don’t assume collecting contact details first is always the best sequence.
Follow-up for people who didn’t book immediately
Not everyone watches a video and schedules a call straight away.
We also built automated follow-up emails to keep educating interested prospects who hadn’t booked. That gave the campaign a way to continue the conversation.
Good follow-up should reinforce the problem, explain the approach, and answer objections. It shouldn’t just repeat “schedule a call” in every email.
The messaging mattered more than the funnel pages
Anyone can assemble funnel pages these days. That doesn’t mean the funnel will persuade the right people to book.
The messaging is where much of the work happens.
For this campaign, we connected the MYGA offer to something prospects already understood: money sitting in savings accounts or CDs.
That made the conversation more concrete than a generic “learn about annuities” message.
The ad needed to earn attention. The landing page needed to make that attention feel relevant.
Then the VSL needed to explain the alternatives and why someone might want to discuss the client’s approach.
Your ad, landing page, video, and follow-up should feel like one conversation, not four unrelated sales pitches.
We kept the exact campaign messaging private. But the underlying mechanism is worth understanding.
Start with the person’s problem, then introduce the product as a potential solution. Don’t expect a product label alone to create demand.
I also draw on what we’ve learned from other client campaigns. That helps us avoid mistakes we’ve already encountered, rather than starting every message from scratch.
It doesn’t remove the need to test. Different offers, audiences, and firms still produce different results.
For the video structure behind that process, see how to create a video sales letter.
Keep MYGA comparisons accurate
The historical campaign discussed potential interest of 4% to 6%. That was campaign context, not a current rate quote or a promise.
Any live message needs to reflect current carrier terms and approved disclosures. A MYGA is not an FDIC-insured savings account or CD.
Insurer guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. Contract terms, surrender charges, liquidity needs, and suitability also matter.
FINRA’s annuity overview explains the broader product risks and distinctions.
The marketing goal is to generate an informed conversation. It isn’t to decide whether an annuity suits someone before reviewing their circumstances.
The results: $430 initially, then $395 per MYGA appointment
During the first 30 days, Meta Ads generated booked appointments at about $430 each.
Meta includes both Facebook and Instagram. Considering this client’s asset threshold and limited-state audience, I thought that was a strong starting point.
But we didn’t stop at the first result.
We reviewed the ads and VSL data and identified small changes that could improve the campaign. After those adjustments, Meta’s cost per appointment came down to $395.
Here’s the reported sequence:
| Campaign stage | Reported result | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Estimate before launch | About $500 to $700 per appointment | Based on the asset profile and smaller geography |
| Meta Ads, first 30 days | About $430 per booked appointment | Initial Facebook and Instagram results |
| TikTok test | Roughly twice Meta’s initial appointment cost | Same ads, funnel, and landing pages |
| Meta Ads after adjustments | $395 per booked appointment | Reported after the first 30 days |
The $395 figure was a later campaign result, not the first-month average. The video doesn’t specify the exact adjustments or complete later reporting window.
These are advertising costs per booked appointment, not all-in marketing costs. The case study reports bookings, not attendance, sales, or revenue.
✅ We improved the campaign using its own data, rather than treating the first month as the final answer.
Results vary between campaigns. This example shows what happened for this client, not a guaranteed MYGA appointment price.
For broader audience-based benchmarks, see our financial advisor appointment-cost guide.
Why we stopped the TikTok test and focused on Meta
We ran the same ads and funnel on TikTok as well as Meta.
The difference was clear. TikTok appointments cost roughly twice as much as the initial Meta appointments.
So we stopped the TikTok campaign and focused on Meta moving forward.
That was a practical decision based on this client’s numbers. We didn’t need to keep spending on both channels just to say we were using both.
I’ve seen a similar pattern in other campaigns targeting smaller locations or narrower audiences. Meta has often produced the lower appointment cost.
My explanation is that Meta gives us more room to reach suitable prospects in those restricted audiences. That’s an interpretation of the pattern, not proof of one cause.
Today, Facebook and Instagram are our core paid channels. The TikTok test belongs here because it explains an actual decision in this campaign.
🎯 Keep the channel that produces the better business opportunity, not the channel that sounds more fashionable.
A test is useful when it changes what you do next. In this case, it helped us decide where to focus.
If you want help testing a MYGA offer without spreading your budget across unnecessary channels, schedule a call with us.
How this compares with buying annuity leads
Another useful comparison is the cost of buying contact details and trying to turn them into conversations.
I’ve spoken with advisors paying about $200 to $300 per purchased lead. Some reported reaching only one in ten of those contacts.
Those are experiences advisors shared with me, not universal lead-provider statistics.
But they show why the price per lead can be misleading.
| Illustrative purchased-lead scenario | Lead spend needed to reach one person |
|---|---|
| $200 to $300 per lead, reaching one in ten | $2,000 to $3,000 |
| $200 to $300 per lead, reaching one in five | $1,000 to $1,500 |
Reaching a person isn’t the same as getting a self-booked appointment. The comparison shows contact costs, not equal qualification or attendance across both methods.
The MYGA campaign generated bookings after prospects saw the client’s marketing and completed the booking journey.
That’s a different experience from receiving a contact who may not recognize your firm.
With a firm-owned system, the ads and funnel introduce you from the beginning. You also have more control over the message, qualification, and follow-up.
For this client, leads generated through the system went only to them. We weren’t sharing those inquiries with competing advisors.
Ownership matters because the system builds familiarity with your firm, not just a list of people to call.
Our annuity leads guide explains exclusive and shared approaches in more detail. This case study provides a specific example of the owned-system approach.
What I’d consider next to improve a MYGA campaign
The campaign was already producing appointments below my original estimate. But I could still see opportunities worth considering.
These were proposed next steps, not additional results already measured for this client.
Consider a wider permitted geography
A larger audience can give Meta more opportunities to find responsive prospects.
If your business can serve additional states, expanding the campaign may help reduce appointment cost. That’s something to evaluate, not an automatic instruction to target everywhere.
Confirm licensing, carrier availability, and advertising requirements before expanding. Only include states where your firm can appropriately market and serve the offer.
Then compare actual appointment quality and cost. A cheaper booking isn’t helpful if the firm cannot serve that person.
Add YouTube to build more familiarity
The other opportunity was creating relevant YouTube videos.
A prospect who has watched one ad and a five-minute VSL has some context. Someone who has watched several useful videos has spent much more time learning from you.
In my experience, that deeper familiarity can make sales conversations easier. Across other clients, I’ve also seen content support attendance and conversion.
YouTube can generate organic inquiries without paid distribution. But it still requires time, planning, and useful videos.
For this MYGA offer, content could explain questions people already have about savings alternatives and the tradeoffs they need to consider.
Those topics need accurate product information and the appropriate compliance review. The goal is helpful education, not a collection of exaggerated rate claims.
For a separate example of this approach, see our annuity YouTube and blog SEO case study.
Improve the weak point, not everything at once
For your own campaign, review the journey in order:
- Are the ads attracting people who fit the offer?
- Are those people engaging with the VSL?
- Are suitable prospects completing the application and booking?
- Are booked appointments attending and progressing toward a client relationship?
That gives you a clearer next action than rebuilding the entire funnel because one number feels high.
In this campaign, small ad and VSL adjustments helped. Another campaign might need a different change.
Frequently asked questions about MYGA lead generation
Can Meta Ads generate MYGA appointments for under $400?
Yes, this client campaign reached $395 per booked appointment after the initial 30 days and subsequent adjustments.
The audience target was more than $200,000 in investable assets across a few states. That’s a campaign-specific result, not a guaranteed cost.
What did the MYGA campaign cost per appointment in its first month?
Meta Ads generated booked appointments at about $430 each during the first 30 days. The later reported figure was $395.
The $500 to $700 range was my estimate before launch, not a previous campaign result.
Who was the client trying to reach?
The client wanted prospects with more than $200,000 in investable assets who were interested in earning more interest on excess cash.
The campaign ran in a few states. It wasn’t a nationwide campaign.
Why did Meta perform better than TikTok in this case study?
TikTok produced appointments at roughly twice Meta’s initial cost using the same ads and funnel. We stopped that test and focused on Meta.
I’ve often seen Meta perform better with smaller geographic audiences. That pattern doesn’t prove every campaign will behave the same way.
Do I need to buy annuity leads to generate MYGA appointments?
No. An owned campaign can attract exclusive inquiries through your ads, video, qualification process, and calendar.
For the wider comparison, read our guide to exclusive annuity leads.
Was $395 the cost per client acquired?
No. It was the reported advertising cost per booked appointment, not the cost per sale or an all-in marketing cost.
A booking still needs to turn into an attended conversation and a suitable client relationship. Track those outcomes separately.
Can YouTube support a MYGA lead-generation campaign?
Yes, relevant educational videos can build familiarity and generate organic inquiries. Creating those videos was an improvement idea here, not a measured result for this client.
Keep product explanations accurate and review them for compliance before publishing.
Build a MYGA appointment system around your firm
The most useful lesson isn’t simply that one client reached $395 appointments.
We started with a specific prospect problem and a defined audience. Then we built a booking journey, tested channels, and used the data to improve.
That’s the approach I’d bring to your firm as well.
Start with the people you want to serve. Give them a clear reason to learn more, then make the next step straightforward.
If you want help building a MYGA lead-generation and appointment system, schedule a call with us.
We can discuss your offer, serviceable states, budget, and the support that makes sense for your business. You can also review our packages and pricing before we speak.